news
Anthropology and Sociology
02 December 2019

How elites shape unequal democracies: Perceptions of redistribution in Brazil and South Africa

Professor Graziella Moraes Silva has recently  been granted an SNF grant for her project. This project will contribute to the debate about elites and inequality by shifting the focus from how elites benefit from inequality to how elites may support redistribution.

Principal Investigator (PI): Graziella Moraes Silva
Post-doctoral Researcher: Matias López
PhD Research Assistant: Livio Miles Silva Muller

Project Summary


The role of elites in the reproduction of inequalities has received increasing attention in recent years. The current literature has focused on measuring the growth of income and wealth inequality at the top, identifying how policy outputs are biased toward the preferences of wealthier voters, and analysing elite practices of reproduction. Nevertheless, the vast majority of these studies explicitly or implicitly assume that it is always in the interest of elites to increase inequality and oppose redistribution. Far less attention has been given to the conditions under which elites are likely to support and promote redistributive agendas.


This proposal builds on an emerging literature and exploratory fieldwork that suggests that elites can be supportive of redistribution, especially when they see it as suiting their interests and mitigating the negative consequences of poverty and inequality in their own lives. Their support, however, is articulated through and mediated by cultural processes that remain underexplored (and often unaccounted for) in current studies about elites and inequality.


This project will contribute to the debate about elites and inequality by shifting the focus from how elites benefit from inequality to how elites may support redistribution. In particular, we focus on elite perceptions as mechanisms that may enable or constrain support for redistributive policies. The project will collect and analyse data in two of the most unequal democracies in the world, Brazil and South Africa, where redistribution has been a key issue of political debate. The research will rely on a multi-method design, combining (1) estimation of the average effects of perception on elite support for redistribution and (2) identification of the cultural processes that enable this support.
We define “elites” as individuals capable of influencing political life due to their positions in powerful organizations and institutions. Based on such a power-based conceptualization of elites, this project will analyse the perceptions of individuals in leadership positions in influential market and political institutions. We will focus on three main groups of elites in each country: businesspeople (CEOs, CFOs, and Chairpersons of the Boards of major companies), elected officials (at national level), and top-tier civil servants.


By highlighting the cultural processes that mediate the relationship between material (i.e., economic) incentives and policy outputs, this study will contribute to both the political economy literature on unequal democracies and a growing sociological debate about the role of culture in shaping inequality. More broadly, we believe that cultural processes may help to explain why, in spite of relative consensus that inequality is one the most pressing social issues today, political mobilization among elites in response to it has been weak.

 

 

 

 

Keywords: Graziella Moraes Silva; Anthropology and Sociology; Research Projects