Research page
CCDP

Young Venezuelan Migrants in Colombia’s Urban Peripheries: Criminals, Criminalized or Change-Makers?

Photo credit (banner): Elena Butti

Project description 

In recent years, the humanitarian crisis in Venezuela has led to a massive inflow of Venezuelan migrants to neighbouring Colombia.  In the lack of proper reception facilities, the vast majority of these migrants resettle in city peripheries – spaces largely controlled by criminal narco-gangs, where the most disadvantaged sectors of the Colombian population live. This two-year project (2023-2025), funded by the SNSF, seeks to ethnographically explore the experiences of these migrants, and specifically their relationship with the criminal groups that operate in the areas where they settle. 

Following an initial round of fieldwork, the project is focussing more specifically on these migrants’ access to informal housing and the role of criminal gangs in this illegal rental and land market at the city peripheries. Initial findings reveal that, as part of their diversification of income strategy, criminal gangs in Medellín have started to take a more active role in this illegal housing market. Over the past decade, the occupation, plotting and construction of private land, which used to be an organic process performed independently by the occupying residents, has been increasingly co-opted by criminal gangs, which now play a central role in managing and profiting from this informal housing market which rapidly expanded as a response to the migration crisis. Using Verónica Gago’s concept of ‘neoliberalism from below’ (Gago, 2014) and Gago and Mezzadra’s (2017) notion of ‘urban extractivism’ (see also García Jerez, 2019), this project shows that gang-controlled informal housing markets represent the neoliberal capture of decades of popular self-organization, and represent gangs’ own way of benefitting from the migration crisis.

The project is hosted at the Centre on Conflict, Development and Peacebuilding of the IHEID, and will also involve a collaboration the Universidad Nacional de Colombia.

Associated projects can be found on www.elenabutti.com

KEY EVENTS OF THE PROJECT

2024

During 2024, the PI conducted an initial round of fieldwork (4 months, March-June 2025), through which she has gained good access to the main focus neighbourhood, has visited it daily, and got close to a dozen of families with whom she has held continuous contact since. She also published two book chapters and one article, and has several other publications in preparation. She produced three short ethnographic films on the realities of the neighbourhood (to be released in 2025). 

Further, Dr. Butti delivered two keynote addresses (Fundación Paz Ciudadana and European Association of Social Anthropologists Early-Career Keynote) and delivered two invited seminars (Geneva Graduate Institute and London School of Economics) and presentations at seven conferences (Global Initiative on Transnational Organized Crime; EASA Biennial; Society for Latin American Studies Annual Meeting; Latin American Studies Association Annual Meeting; Justice Juvénile et Vie Quotidienne dans les Périphéries Urbaines at Université de Fribourg; Gangs ERC Project Final Workshop; From Global to Local: Gangs, Racism, Criminalisation, and the Empowerment of Youths, University of California, Riverside). She has also organized two conferencesSouth-South Migration: The Venezuelan Case and Beyond (Universidad Nacional de Colombia) and Juvenicide: Conceptualizing, measuring, preventing & countering systematic violence against young people (Universitat Pompeu Fabra - with externally secured funding by the Wenner-Gren Foundation).

During 2024, Dr. Butti has also been a Visiting Professor at the Faculty of Human and Economic Sciences, National University of Colombia in Medellín (March-May 2024) as well as a Visiting Researcher at the Department of Communications of the Universitat Pompeu Fabra (November 2024 - with externally secured funding by the Independent Social Research Foundation). She has moreover continued serving as Secretary General of the Société Suisse des Américanistes (SSA). Finally, she has acted as the secondary supervisor for the thesis projects of Joelle Cervantes (Msc in International Development (MINT), Geneva Graduate Institute) and William Cardenas Mesa (Swiss Government Excellence Scholarship, Geneva Graduate Institute).

Key Publications:

Butti, E. [forthcoming 2025]. Youth are not all the same: On the appropriateness and limits of participatory methods when studying youth in contexts of marginalization. Social Sciences, Special Issue Researching Youth on the Move: Methods, Ethics and Emotions, eds. N. Hansen and C. Feixa.

Butti, E., Van Damme, E. and Ziosi, E. [forthcoming 2025]. Gangs and organized crime in Latin America: Boundaries, intersections, and articulations. In Eurogang edited volume, eds. D. Carson, M. Urbanik and R. Shanon. London: Springer.

Butti, E. (2024). Safe and Ethical Ethnography: Looking Inwards. In Inclusive Ethnography: Making fieldwork safer, healthier and more ethical, eds. C. Procter and B. Spector, pp. 18-32. London: SAGE.